Who has the authority to say if a Mass or an ordination is valid or not?
Keith B., you're asking a question of which you probably believe the answer is self-evident: who has the authority to say if a Mass or an ordination is valid or not?
The Catholic answer to that question is not as simple as you believe. A Pope cannot do whatever he pleases. He must conform with dogma and tradition. What Pope Paul VI did in 1968 was similar to what the Anglican Reformers did in the 16th Century: they adapted … [More]

We all know that there have been numerous violations from renegade priests but these were the acts of individuals who have serious problems with their faith and can't be considered as a result of Vatican II or the new Mass. Vatican II was and is truly the work of the Holy Spirit. Sadly, there has been much confusion since Vatican II but there is still only one true Church! If some of the clergy have strayed (some severely) then we should pray for them. On top of all that, who has the authority … [More]

This is a great example of neo-protestantism. Neo, radical, traditionalist, who deny the workings of the Holy Spirit. There was no mention of the horrible abuse that went on during the latin Mass prior to Vatican II. I am old enough to have seen it. Jesus said the attacks will come from all sides. Protestantism is a scourge on Christianty , this video is an example of one of these vicious attacks. This video is a direct attack on the person of the Holy Spirit. Which is a direct attack on God, … [More]

the maker of this video, "Brother" "Michael Dimond, belongs to a Independent"Monastery' that is not recognized by ANY Church,or Bishop Catholic or otherwise, but is a Sedevacantist, who has founded his own Church

don throw the baby out with the dirty bathwater

so, what you are saying is the owners/founders of THIS website are nor really Ordained priests?and the Holy mass they Celebrate is Invalid??

give me a break, illicit yes, but not invalid...Sedevacantists are just as Protestants