Jungerheld
13471
Has the Church reached her, "Dunkirk Moment"?
ericsammons.com

The Church’s Dunkirk Moment

One of the greatest military events of the 20th century was not a victorious battle, but a hasty retreat. On May 27, 1940, the “Miracle of Dunkirk” began. British, French, …
Ultraviolet
Sure is re-runs in here. @Be Ye Repetitive You were pushing this garbage just a day or so back. Okay, re-run time... Vatican II.
YOU want to invalidate Vatican Council II because ONE statement in ONE of those sixteen documents contradicts your un-Catholic ant-Semitic bigotry that was already condemned BEFORE Vatican Council II by Pope Pius XI in 1938.
You've got an uphill climb with that since …More
Sure is re-runs in here. @Be Ye Repetitive You were pushing this garbage just a day or so back. Okay, re-run time... Vatican II.
YOU want to invalidate Vatican Council II because ONE statement in ONE of those sixteen documents contradicts your un-Catholic ant-Semitic bigotry that was already condemned BEFORE Vatican Council II by Pope Pius XI in 1938.

You've got an uphill climb with that since Cardinal Brandmuller stated
---...
all of the Conciliar documents “must be taken seriously as an expression of the living Magisterium;”

annnnnnnd
Archbishop Agostino Marchetto, added, importantly: “There must be an acceptance of the Council by those who want to be reunited with the Church. I don’t think the SSPX can say, ‘Well, we’ll set this or that document aside.’
---

..not just the SSPX, either. That's what fake-Catholic anti-Semites do as well.

If a document is not automatically binding to all Catholics that does not show the document does not apply to any Catholic or that statements within a document are not valid teachings of the Catholic Church.

Schismatics and other error-prone people like build a massive fallacy of composition along such reasoning. What's bugging you is the Catholic Church is throwing your mentor E. Michael Jones a big middle finger. Same one Pope Pius XI , was throwing ten years before Jones was even born. While literally sitting on the Seat of St. Peter,

The Big Deal With China.

Pope Francis' "deal" actually ratifies the Vatican's final authority for selecting bishops in China. (from wiki)

--"However, in September 2018 China and the Holy See signed an agreement allowing the Pope to appoint and veto bishops approved by the Communist Party of China."--

--"...While the agreement states that China will recommend bishops before they are appointed by the popeit also stipulates that the pope has authority to veto a bishop China recommends."
--

So technically, your statement. "(such as giving the authority of selecting the Chinese bishops, to the atheist Communist Chinese Government that persecutes Catholics,) " is wrong.

Since Pope Francis has the final say to appoint and veto Chinese bishops, he retains authority in the matter and the Chinese government accepts that.

--With regard to the provisional agreement, Pope Francis said that “what is here is dialogue about the eventual candidates. This is done in dialogue. But Rome nominates, the pope nominates. That is clear!”--

www.americamagazine.org/…/pope-francis-ex…

The common perception of the "deal" and the provisions within it are technically very different.
F M Shyanguya
Be Ye Separate
Our Holy Catholic Church has reached the prophesy of St. Paul. (2Thessalonians2) The Apostasy.
Vatican 2 was different than all other revolts, such as the French Revolution or Luther's revolt, the Vatican 2 revolt was from enemies who stole seats of authority within the Church, such as PaulVl.
"As if abandonment of the tiara wasn't symbolic enough the bizarre behavior continued when on 4 October …More
Our Holy Catholic Church has reached the prophesy of St. Paul. (2Thessalonians2) The Apostasy.
Vatican 2 was different than all other revolts, such as the French Revolution or Luther's revolt, the Vatican 2 revolt was from enemies who stole seats of authority within the Church, such as PaulVl.
"As if abandonment of the tiara wasn't symbolic enough the bizarre behavior continued when on 4 October 1965 Paul VI visited the United Nations in New York City during the 4th session of the Second Vatican Council. There Paul VI said the United Nations was mankind's last hope of a universal organization which could bring about world peace! Unbelievable? Wait there's more! Paul VI then gave his papal cross and papal ring to Mr. U Than, the General Secretary of the United Nations. Why did he do this? To help the poor of course by auctioning them off!" ( The Day Paul VI Ditched The Tiara - Call me Gorge blog)
False Francis' chronic acts of lawlessness, (such as giving the authority of selecting the Chinese bishops, to the atheist Communist Chinese Government that persecutes Catholics,) are revealed in Apostle Paul's prophesy also.
The Vatican 2 documents, NOT protected by the infallibility of the Holy Spirit, are the ambiguous teachings that make up the false Bible, for the antiChrist Church.
- Apostle Paul to the Galatians:
"that certain people are causing disquiet among you, in their eagerness to pervert the gospel of Christ.
Friends, though it were we ourselves, though it were an angel from heaven that should preach to you a gospel other than the gospel we preached to you, a curse upon him!"
Brother Timothy Marie shares this
1
Truth.
Swiss MP on IslamMore
Truth.

Swiss MP on Islam