There is a twofold error within the archbishop’s very ingenious but problematic analysis. First, my analysis of Pope Francis as embodying two roles, that of Pontiff and that of being the practical leader of schismatic elements in the Church, is not the dividing of him into two different personae – that of Pontiff and that of the exuberant Argentinian. Rather, the problem I was calling attention…More
There is a twofold error within the archbishop’s very ingenious but problematic analysis. First, my analysis of Pope Francis as embodying two roles, that of Pontiff and that of being the practical leader of schismatic elements in the Church, is not the dividing of him into two different personae – that of Pontiff and that of the exuberant Argentinian. Rather, the problem I was calling attention to is not that they are two in some schizoid manner, but that they are one – Pope Francis as the authentic pontiff is the same person, the same pope, who is encouraging and allowing schismatic elements to take root within the Church. This “oneness” is precisely what makes the situation so dangerous and worrisome.
Tesa

A Response to Archbishop Viganò’s Letter about Vatican II – Catholic World Report

Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, then apostolic nuncio to the United States, speaks Nov. 16 during the opening of the 2015 fall general assembly of …
jjjorge1
First Archbishop Vigano is not in "schism" for noting points in VC II that are at variance with the Tradition. See for example the work of Romano Amerio a Swiss Italian theologian and a peritus (theological expert) of Bishop Angelo Giuseppe Jelmini who actually attended the ill fated council. His magnum opus Iota Unum is a work dedicated to the study of the ruptures in Church teaching and …More
First Archbishop Vigano is not in "schism" for noting points in VC II that are at variance with the Tradition. See for example the work of Romano Amerio a Swiss Italian theologian and a peritus (theological expert) of Bishop Angelo Giuseppe Jelmini who actually attended the ill fated council. His magnum opus Iota Unum is a work dedicated to the study of the ruptures in Church teaching and tradition following the Second Vatican Council. Amerio was a faithful and devout Catholic until the end of his life. One can not be in "schism" for pointing out that 2+2 does not equal 5. So read Iota Unum (www.amazon.com/…/0963903217) and learn something and stop talking in ignorance. For those who don't have the stamina to read Iota Unum see Dr Taylor Marshall's short video here (www.youtube.com/watch) - this old trick of smearing those who have honest questions with parts of VCII text as being "in schism" - simply will not do - enough. already.
Alex A
And of those who 'delight' in such divisions? That is, if they be so 'toxic' as your obvious theological expertise deduces. Admit it F M -You are no Thomas Aquinas nor an expert on the rise of the Traditional Movement in the church. In fact, you are anti-tradition ergo, not a proponent of the Apostles Creed or even the Nicene Creed. So the question becomes thus: What sort of Catholic do you …More
And of those who 'delight' in such divisions? That is, if they be so 'toxic' as your obvious theological expertise deduces. Admit it F M -You are no Thomas Aquinas nor an expert on the rise of the Traditional Movement in the church. In fact, you are anti-tradition ergo, not a proponent of the Apostles Creed or even the Nicene Creed. So the question becomes thus: What sort of Catholic do you perceive yourself to be if not a believer in the traditional codified beliefs of the Church?
Scapular
Deo Gratias and gratitude to you Archbishop Viganò, keep speaking!

JMJ
Dear Excellency
Quoting from the Gospel of St John chapter 10.

We the little people of the Church are so grateful to Our Lord that He has given us a Shepherd prepared to guard the sheep door. 2
But he that entereth in by the door is the shepherd of the sheep. See moreDG +AB Vigano we stand with you "PETITION"
F M Shyanguya
“If it appears that the ultra-progressive liberal agenda is the work of the devil, so the ultra-conservative agenda is also the work of the devil. And, in the midst of these warring factions, the devil rejoices.”

For some time now, I have seen the Traditionalists movement as none other than the other side of the coin of the crisis the Devil has whipped up within the Church. Why, they have in …More
“If it appears that the ultra-progressive liberal agenda is the work of the devil, so the ultra-conservative agenda is also the work of the devil. And, in the midst of these warring factions, the devil rejoices.”

For some time now, I have seen the Traditionalists movement as none other than the other side of the coin of the crisis the Devil has whipped up within the Church. Why, they have in common a hatred, an intense hatred for Pope St John Paul II.

It is said temptations come in pairs.

They fell via the temptation of the good.