“Vatican swiftly excommunicated 6 SSPX bishops after their illicit ordinations, defying Pope Leo XIV’s appeal. Canonist Fr. Murray clarifies the decree targets the bishops primarily; priests & laity aren’t automatically excommunicated by mere attendance—‘formal adherence’ to schism requires clear acts, not just attending TLM. A canonical mess with warnings, but the laity seeking Tradition remain safe in good faith. Important discussion on unity, liturgy, and avoiding unnecessary division in the Church.
3 more comments from Fides Et Ratio
Quotes and Sources
On formal adherence:
“The lay faithful who formally adhere to the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X under the conditions established in the Explanatory Note of the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts of 1996… are to be considered schismatic and excommunicated.” (Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Decree of 2 July 2026).56
The 1996 note specifies that formal adherence involves “freely and consciously sharing the substance of the schism” (internal) and external signs such as “exclusive participation in the Lefebvrian ‘ecclesial’ acts, without taking part in the acts of the Catholic Church.” Casual sharing of news and analysis does not meet this threshold. (Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts, Explanatory Note, 24 August 1996).61
Saint Thomas Aquinas:
“Faith is the foundation of the Church… and the unity of the Church depends on the unity of faith.” (Summa Theologica II-II, q. 39, a. 1). He teaches that fraternal correction and critique of error must serve charity and remain within the Church’s visible unity.
Saint Robert Bellarmine:
“The Church is one… governed by the successor of Peter… It is not lawful to oppose the Roman Pontiff.” (De Romano Pontifice, Book IV). Bellarmine stresses that even strong defense of tradition must preserve communion with the Pope as the principle of unity.
Current theologians (example):
Canonist J.D. Flynn notes that “formal adherence” requires deliberate rejection of papal authority beyond mere attendance or discussion of traditional perspectives. (The Pillar, July 2026 analysis). Many contemporary voices such as those in traditional scholarship affirm that faithful critique of errors, when joined to charity and unity, serves the Church without schism.