Clicks1.9K
en.news
4

Swiss Bishop Celebrates Pentecost High Mass In PiusX Seminary

Retired Chur Bishop Vitus Huonder, 79, Switzerland, celebrated the Pentecost Pontifical High Mass in the PiusX Seminary (SSPX) in Zaitzkofen, Germany (full video below).

Huonder has been living at the Institut Sancta Maria, a Pius X grammar school in Wangs, St Gallen, Switzerland, since his retirement in 2019. It is rare that bishops, even retired ones, celebrate publicly for PiusX.

#newsUcqljnphir

proUnaSanctaCatholicaetApostolicaEcclesia
Why does FSSPX still wants to be part of Bergoglios Antichurch, which is the church a „new religion“ (fsspx quote) ???😩🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
philosopher
@Ultraviolet I never claimed that the bishop was pure or not infallible, but his actions reflecting what some retired bishops choose to do upon retirement, which is to reside with an orthodox Catholic religious order, such as the Benedictines or Trappist monks.

By your logic we could say the same of a bishop in charge of the CDF that they are not infallible. What matters, whether they or any …More
@Ultraviolet I never claimed that the bishop was pure or not infallible, but his actions reflecting what some retired bishops choose to do upon retirement, which is to reside with an orthodox Catholic religious order, such as the Benedictines or Trappist monks.

By your logic we could say the same of a bishop in charge of the CDF that they are not infallible. What matters, whether they or any priestly order are in conformity with the orthodox Apostolic Tradition.

Lastly, I would note that the former president of the pontifical commission Eclessia Dei, Cardinal Castrillon Hoyas 2000-2009, has said, "technically they (SSPX) never made any complete schism or heresy. For example, they did not create a separate jurisdiction, b/c to create a separate jurisdiction outside the jurisdiction of the Church, that means you want to separate." He has also added that the the views of the SSPX are reactions to the incorrect interpretation of Vatican 2 documents and not the Council itself. (Source- Romereports)
Ultraviolet
CDF prefect disagrees. @philosopher Catholic bishops are not infallible. Witness the German bishops and the insanities they promote and support via their "Synodal Path". pic related.
philosopher
I think this demonstrates that the SSPX is in the Church and are not in schism. A Catholic bishop in good standing could not celebrate mass, or live in residence with a schismatic order. This is not an ecumenical prayerful accompaniment with Anglicans or the Orthodox.