Ruini Commission: Medjugorje Seers Are Not Mature In Faith, One Is Notorious Liar
The journalist David Murgia, leaked excerpts of the thirty-page Medjugorje report of Cardinal Ruini’s commission which was launched 2010 (IlSegnoDiGiona.com, February 7). The report claims “with …More
The journalist David Murgia, leaked excerpts of the thirty-page Medjugorje report of Cardinal Ruini’s commission which was launched 2010 (IlSegnoDiGiona.com, February 7).
The report claims “with reasonable certainty," that "the first seven apparitions" are "intrinsically credible,” calling the hypothesis of a demonic origin unfounded.
Its fallacious main argument is Medjugorje's “positive fruits.” The commission voted 13 to 1 that the phenomenon’s beginning wasn't attributable to manipulation or human dynamics alone "but had a supernatural origin.”
However, it noticed a "repetitive banality” of some of the Medjugorje messages, misses elements of transcendence [miracles], and advises that the "linguistic formulation" of the still ongoing messages should be overseen [and corrected?] by a priest.
The seers have “a relation, ambiguous in certain aspects, with money,” the report notices, and “do not, in fact, appear mature either in their faith or in their ecclesiality, and at certain times …More
The report claims “with reasonable certainty," that "the first seven apparitions" are "intrinsically credible,” calling the hypothesis of a demonic origin unfounded.
Its fallacious main argument is Medjugorje's “positive fruits.” The commission voted 13 to 1 that the phenomenon’s beginning wasn't attributable to manipulation or human dynamics alone "but had a supernatural origin.”
However, it noticed a "repetitive banality” of some of the Medjugorje messages, misses elements of transcendence [miracles], and advises that the "linguistic formulation" of the still ongoing messages should be overseen [and corrected?] by a priest.
The seers have “a relation, ambiguous in certain aspects, with money,” the report notices, and “do not, in fact, appear mature either in their faith or in their ecclesiality, and at certain times …More
Novella Nurney
- Report
Change comment
Remove comment
Go figure. The hundreds of absurd scheduled " apparitions " repetitive, often heretical messages, numerous orthdox prelates and theologians screaming " stay away " and yet , still, thousands upon thousands of souls follow novelty in direct opposition to Holy Mother Church. Micheal Davies ( the Welshman) wrote an excellent set of articles on this topic. To add insult, I've been "damned to hell " ( …More
Go figure. The hundreds of absurd scheduled " apparitions " repetitive, often heretical messages, numerous orthdox prelates and theologians screaming " stay away " and yet , still, thousands upon thousands of souls follow novelty in direct opposition to Holy Mother Church. Micheal Davies ( the Welshman) wrote an excellent set of articles on this topic. To add insult, I've been "damned to hell " ( even though no Catholic is EVER required to believe ANY private revelation for the salvation of thier soul, if it is not in the deposit of faith , it is private) by more Medjugorje followers than Saint's homilies. Lord have mercy!