Burke: Often Mentioned "Francis Magisterium" Is Not The Magisterium

A soon-to-be-published “Catechism of the Catholic Church with Theological Commentary,” edited by Curia Archbishop Rino Fisichella, will "not have the authority” of the 1994 Catechism, said Cardinal …
Eva
Cardinal Burke will be marching for life with the Guadalupe Shrine group in Washington DC this week at the March for Life.
Since the infiltrations of modernist heresy have been proven in many writings after Vatican II. The Code that we must follow is the original Code of Canon Law of 1917 promulgated by Pope Benedict XV, which by the way confirmed the bull "Cum ex apostolatus" that annuls the elevation of a heretic to the papacy.
F M Shyanguya and one more user like this.
F M Shyanguya likes this.
nacelt1 likes this.
john333
PF and the gang that elected him has been talking heresy for decades the Popes in the pass new their theology and did nothing but instead excommunicated SSPX.
Ratzinger did not do his job when was head of CDF and as Pope
JPII AND BVI left us this mess
If you apply what Cardinal Burke says to John Paul II, Pius XII or Saint Pius X you will find that it does not work. To say that not everything done officially by a pope is part of his magisterium, is to say he has no magisterium. But a pope is not simply the head of an Anglican communion. So Burke needs to clarify his theology here, is he saying Bergoglio is not the pope. If so, he is correct. …More
If you apply what Cardinal Burke says to John Paul II, Pius XII or Saint Pius X you will find that it does not work. To say that not everything done officially by a pope is part of his magisterium, is to say he has no magisterium. But a pope is not simply the head of an Anglican communion. So Burke needs to clarify his theology here, is he saying Bergoglio is not the pope. If so, he is correct. But if he is saying that a Pope does not have an intrinsic magisterium or a grace to be infallible in teaching, then he has denied the dogmatic definitions of Vatican I.
Money Laundering Mass Goer likes this.
It is easy to know exactly what Burke will not say: Anything indicating any doubt that Bergoglio is pope.
Money Laundering Mass Goer likes this.
elbow
"The authority of 1994" Schoenbornian Catechism is very great indeed because it is the first catechism of so-called New Advent and New Evangelisation. And new confession of belief. The lavender lobby was also at work there.
The Roman Catechism . Everyone should at least download a free copy for reference purposes.
DEFENSA DE LA FE likes this.
The 1994 muslims and jews together with us worship the same God catechism will still have authority he says. The neo-conservative modernist against the neo-liberal modernists.
elbow and one more user like this.
elbow likes this.
Novella Nurney likes this.
Cardinal Burke effectively states that “francis 1st” the alleged pope, has no magisterium.
Frà Alexis Bugnolo and one more user like this.
Frà Alexis Bugnolo likes this.
DEFENSA DE LA FE likes this.
artemiusz likes this.
Latin Mass vs. Novus Ordo. Benedict XVI vs. Francis. Catechism "A" vs. Catechsim "B". Schism? What Schism???
Lalanz likes this.
elbow
There is no schism between 1994 and 2019. Only evolution. The postconciliar diverse polyhedron has slightly mutated. And Bergoglio is just a little bit more progressive than younger Ratzinger.
elbow
PS Several weeks ago I got to know that JMB did not coin the "ecological conversion" term - it was used by JPII at the Midsummer of the Postconciliar Spring.
Evolution and slightly mutated polyhedrons, elbow? That's even better than the nonsense coming from Marx and Bergoglio's spokespeople. They should put you on the payroll. "Evolution" can justify every "slightly mutated polyhedron" right through The Feast Of The Blessed Pachamama, co-celebrated by Father Ellen DeGeneres and her spouse Portia at Saint Richard Simmons' parish.

In all fairness, …More
Evolution and slightly mutated polyhedrons, elbow? That's even better than the nonsense coming from Marx and Bergoglio's spokespeople. They should put you on the payroll. "Evolution" can justify every "slightly mutated polyhedron" right through The Feast Of The Blessed Pachamama, co-celebrated by Father Ellen DeGeneres and her spouse Portia at Saint Richard Simmons' parish.

In all fairness, you can't validly claim there isn't grounds for a schism (even a privately held one) between the two catechisms since Pope Francis' revision isn't finished yet. God help us all when it is. .
elbow
@Ultraviolet
Nothing can justify feasts of Pachamama but also nothing could justify the Quran kissing. Have you ever wondered why Bergoglio proclaimed the trinity of Roncalli, Montini and Wojtyla as saints, trying to canonise the post-conciliar revolution?
Talking about Cardinal George Pell, Burke hopes that he will finally receive a just judgment, “There is no question in my mind that the accusation made against him by a single person who remains unidentified could not have plausibly happened in the way in which the Cardinal is accused.”

Burke thinks that the incident did not occur.
Frà Alexis Bugnolo and 2 more users like this.
Frà Alexis Bugnolo likes this.
giveusthisday likes this.
DEFENSA DE LA FE likes this.
About the Dubia against Francis’ Amoris Laetitia, Burke expects that Francis will never answer.

Talking about the notion of “pastoral accompaniment,” Burke said that when people in an irregular matrimonial union are being accompanied, they must be helped to not to receive the sacraments until they are able to rectify their situation.

Burke is “disappointed” that 69 American bishops voted …More
About the Dubia against Francis’ Amoris Laetitia, Burke expects that Francis will never answer.

Talking about the notion of “pastoral accompaniment,” Burke said that when people in an irregular matrimonial union are being accompanied, they must be helped to not to receive the sacraments until they are able to rectify their situation.

Burke is “disappointed” that 69 American bishops voted against calling abortion a “pre-eminent” issue recently: “That is an ominous sign”.
DEFENSA DE LA FE likes this.
One more comment from HerzMariae
"Recently, I talked to two young priests who conveyed a conversation they had with third young priest who was studying moral theology. He said to them: “We have Pope Francis’ magisterium that is completely new; we now have to abandon all the old categories and develop a new theology to match this magisterium.” This is simply preposterous — this is not the magisterium! Priests and the lay …More
"Recently, I talked to two young priests who conveyed a conversation they had with third young priest who was studying moral theology. He said to them: “We have Pope Francis’ magisterium that is completely new; we now have to abandon all the old categories and develop a new theology to match this magisterium.” This is simply preposterous — this is not the magisterium! Priests and the lay faithful must understand this."