en.news

Contradictory Legislation: How Many Cardinals Can Participate?

There is the question of the number of cardinals who will take part in the conclave on 7 May.

Article 33 of the 'Romano Pontifici Eligendo' states that the maximum number of cardinal electors must not exceed 120.

There are no exceptions or derogations. Accordingly, the following article, 34, says: 'We declare null and void any acts by which they would rashly attempt to modify the system or the electoral body'.

But confusion is the daily bread of Francis' Church.

With the latest appointments made by Francis, the number of cardinal electors stands at 135 (including Becciu), a full 15 more than allowed by the Apostolic Constitution promulgated by Paul VI on 1 October 1975.

But the same Constitution adds: "No cardinal-elector may be excluded from the active or passive election of the Supreme Pontiff on account of, or under the pretext of, excommunication, suspension, interdict or any other ecclesiastical impediment".

As a result, no cardinal can be excluded from the election of Francis' successor, who will therefore be chosen by a much larger number of electors than provided for in the Apostolic Constitution.

The problem now is to find accommodation for the cardinals in Santa Marta. The rooms, suitably sealed to ensure the security and confidentiality of the cardinals, are designed to accommodate a maximum of 120 cardinal electors...

#newsAqexmpxukt
11K
John Thomas Larkin

A large portion of the electoral base for this conclave lacks the proper authority to vote.
I make this claim on the basis that only a true pope can make or sanction a cardinal.
The last convincingly really true pope was Benedict xvi. So any man appointed as cardinal after his death has no true authority.
The cardinals sanctioned after pope Benedicts purported resignation might have some authority given that they were wheeled out for his blessing but the entire set up is an utter mess.
But interesting times ahead no doubt.