Liturgy Not Faithful To Vatican II

Cardinal Sarah: "There is a serious illness in the Liturgy" Cardinal Robert Sarah gave an interview to valeursactuelles.com. Summary (by Sanoj Thomas):

• The idea that we are all going to Heaven is not in the Gospel.

• Sin must be denounced and the guilty must be punished.

• Islam is spreading because we [Catholics] are neither missionaries nor fervent in our faith. The advancement of Islam reveals the Christians' tibbility. We don't dare evangelize.

• Liturgy obeys coded standards, inherited from a thousand generations, but Catholic liturgy is sick today.

• Why are so many young people fascinated by ancient liturgy? Let's be honest. It would be very easy to simply say that everyone has a psychological need for identity. But wouldn't it be better to admit that many celebrations disappoint them?

• Liturgy is sometimes believed to be more accessible through the use of secular music, artificially relaxed attitudes, removal of sacred separations and architectural leveling of churches. This is a tragic illusion. All these choices take us further away from God.

• I want to be explicit about Traditionis custodians. There is deep unhappiness and real suffering in the Church surrounding the liturgy.

• Often, parish liturgies are not faithful to Vatican II. For example, Gregorian singing takes the first place, as was requested?

• Current liturgical practice must evolve. It should incorporate the best elements of the ancient in the light of the Council: the Deum or the Cross oriented celebration, the broad use of Latin, the use of the old offering or the prayers said at the foot of the altar.

• A cult that doesn't become culture is an illusion.

• What is happening in Germany [German Synod] is scary. It is an attempt to abandon the Gospel, an attempt at apostasy. The Church there is very rich, very dependent on the State, very connected to the world.

• [The German church] believes that by copying the Protestants, who bless same-sex unions and appoint women as pastors, will succeed. Yet these German Protesting communities have almost no vocation or faith! So, what are we running after?
John A Cassani
Vatican II only decreed that the liturgy was to be “revised,” as soon as possible, and it provided some guidelines for how to accomplish it. It can be said with certainty that the TLM, by the 1962 Missal, is not in line Vatican II. Maybe the 1965 Missal was, but not the 1962, because it is “unrevised” following Sacrosantum Concilium. Cardinal Sarah has his opinion, Pope Benedict XVI had his, Jorge …More
Vatican II only decreed that the liturgy was to be “revised,” as soon as possible, and it provided some guidelines for how to accomplish it. It can be said with certainty that the TLM, by the 1962 Missal, is not in line Vatican II. Maybe the 1965 Missal was, but not the 1962, because it is “unrevised” following Sacrosantum Concilium. Cardinal Sarah has his opinion, Pope Benedict XVI had his, Jorge Bergoglio has his. I think Cardinal Sarah is trying to say that the Novus ordo “can” be Catholic. That is no compliment to a Catholic liturgy. Nor is it a compliment to an ecumenical council to say that it “can” be interpreted in a Catholic way, as long as the right hermeneutic is applied.
Scapular
Can we just say that the Tridentine Mass is faithful to the Council of Trent and if by some remote chance it’s not faithful to Vatican II then it just doesn’t matter because we know it’s 100% Catholic.
Koza Nutria
Trudentine Mass would be faithful to the Vatican II.
When you read V2 documents you will see:
Latin as the main language, gregorian singing, priest facing the altar....and so on.
That what is happening in the most of the parishes is against V2- that's what Sarah is trying to say there.
Many people talk against V2 not knowing what documents actually says about Mass celebrations.More
Trudentine Mass would be faithful to the Vatican II.
When you read V2 documents you will see:
Latin as the main language, gregorian singing, priest facing the altar....and so on.

That what is happening in the most of the parishes is against V2- that's what Sarah is trying to say there.
Many people talk against V2 not knowing what documents actually says about Mass celebrations.