No mea culpa, as Bishop Williamson re‑emerges from the shadows

Matt Stand

Jan 24

An accurate appraisal of the antisemitic problems that plague Catholic “traditionalism”.

Patricia McKeever

Feb 2

Well, "traditionalism" can't plague anything. You must be referring to individuals who may or may not be anti-anything.

giveusthisday

Jan 23

Thank you for the enlightenment re the website. People post all kinds of things on this website, not all or not at all Catholic.

123jussi

2Jan 23

Of those things pertaining to the faith Bishop Williamson is spot on , concerning historical matters who knows? Most people still think Lincoln and FDR were good guys !

Charles Mangerian

2Jan 23

Please note that the linked article is from a website run by hardcore communists who to this day mourn the fall of the Soviet Union and long for a new Chairman Mao or Pol Pot to emerge.

Do I agree with HE Williamson in everything? No. We must as Catholics recognize the good he does & resist at all cost the damnable back biting among self-styled traditionalists. These miserable gossips thrive on rumor & innuendo to attack anyone trying to maintain the Faith in these trying times. Such individuals, and websites, do more damage than anything the Vatican Mafia could do to harm Tradition.

Sean Johnson

Jan 24

Gratuitous

Matt Stand

3Jan 23edited

Williamson is a both heretic and a schismatic. He harbours priests under canonical censure and was responsible for the Urrutigoity affair. And, of course, he’s antisemitic.
His elevation of conspiracies to Church dogmas and, not forgetting, his legendary antisemitism dogmas. He has created his own, false, religion: Ground Zero is his Golgotha; The Protocols of Zion is his Holy Writ; Conspiracy …More

Williamson is a both heretic and a schismatic. He harbours priests under canonical censure and was responsible for the Urrutigoity affair. And, of course, he’s antisemitic.

His elevation of conspiracies to Church dogmas and, not forgetting, his legendary antisemitism dogmas. He has created his own, false, religion: Ground Zero is his Golgotha; The Protocols of Zion is his Holy Writ; Conspiracy Theories is his Cross; Ernst Zündel, David Irvine are his Martyrs etc.

Follow Williamson and you’ll lose your faith.

Louis IX

Jan 23

Please point out his heresies.

Matt Stand

Jan 23

@Louis IX sure.
Bp. Williamson espouses heresies:
#1 The Catholic Church has defected (E.C. 'Various Churches');
#2 Antiquarianism and his appeals to imitate the early Church (see quote below).
A bonus… and also schism:
#3 He rejects the 'One' mark of the Church (“God wants a loose association … but with no structure …” E.C. 'And Now?').
From the Irish Ecclesiastical Record (1889. p. 1036):
“…More

@Louis IX sure.

Bp. Williamson espouses heresies:

#1 The Catholic Church has defected (E.C. 'Various Churches');
#2 Antiquarianism and his appeals to imitate the early Church (see quote below).

A bonus… and also schism:
#3 He rejects the 'One' mark of the Church (“God wants a loose association … but with no structure …” E.C. 'And Now?').

From the Irish Ecclesiastical Record (1889. p. 1036):

“The appeal to antiquity, against the prevailing usage of the Church, it cannot be too constantly borne in mind, is the heretic’s favourite device, and is fraught with danger. As Father Faber has admirably said:-”