You didn't answer my questions. Both the rosary and the brown scapular, along with devotions to the Immaculate and Sacred Hearts were from private revelations. If you say that "you are under no obligation to believe private revelation", however, if you use these things for the salvation of your soul, you contradict yourself in saying what the Church declared is wrong concerning Quito, LaSalette, Fatima and Akita. This is what I point out as erroneous in sede positions. I'd even go so far to say the devil agrees with your position.