French bishops very consciously accepted the principles of the Revolution in the 19th century. Vatican II can be seen as the revenge of the successors of the French minority bishops over Papal Infallibility at Vatican II
Modernist accuses SSPX of having the wrong idea of tradition
All attempts at dialogue have failed: The Society of St. Pius X is heading toward schism. In an interview with katholisch.de, Viennese dogmatic theologian Jan-Heiner Tück explains the roots of the dispute surrounding the Second Vatican Council. Click on the link on the left to see other statements from Professor Tück. They form a modernist pattern The announced illicit episcopal ordinations by the Society of St. Pius X mark a new stage of escalation in the conflict between the community and Rome. To understand the conflict, one must know its background. It involves far more than just the question of the correct form of liturgy; theologically, fundamental issues are at stake, explains Viennese dogmatic theologian Jan-Heiner Tück in an interview with katholisch.de: specifically, the acceptance of the Second Vatican Council and its openness to the world, to other Christian communities, and to non-Christian religions. Question: Professor Tück, what immediately stands out about the Society …