Francis Wants “Respect for Traditions” But Calls Traditional Liturgies "Ideological," "Gnostic"

“It would do us much good to discover that unity is not uniformity but a multifaceted harmony,” Francis said in a video message to religious of Latin America (August 13) - while his Traditionis Custodes has just refused "multifaceted harmony."

The religious should “enter into the life of the people of faith, with respect for their customs and traditions,” he faked advocating for "inculturation" - an ideology which under the pretext of museal "local cultures" destroys the culture of the Church.

According to Francis' ideological view, without inculturation Christian and consecrated life ends up with the "oddest and most ridiculous Gnostic positions" - Francis himself doesn't know what exactly he wants to say with this, "We have seen this, for example, in the misuse of the liturgy. What counts in this is the ideology and not the reality of people - and that is not the Gospel.”

He must be referring to the "oddest and most ridiculous" Novus Ordo improvisations in which ideology counts and not the Gospel, and which have emptied the churches within twenty years.


"This is one of the rules for radicals: accuse your opponents of exactly what you are doing" @Steve D who also replied, "Said the lying, slanderer."
Sorry Catholics don’t lend their ears to non-Catholics for religious instruction.
Dr Bobus
The obvious response is that Novus Ordo liturgies are also ideological.
Rand Miller
Francis speaks out of both sides of his mouth.
Those who are against the traditions of the Church are against the Catholic faith and God
Hugh N. Cry
Fractiones Custodies
Frances is not Catholic.
What could he mean saying "misuse of liturgy" if not the Novus Ordo? Does anyone wish to make a wild guess? I would really like to know...
Dr Bobus
Of course, he's referring to the Novus Ordo. He's playing some CYOA.
Dr Bobus
You don't know what CYOA means?
John A Cassani
He does not speak with authority. Never has.