Thors Catholic Hammer

Catholic sues US bishops for ‘misleading’ faithful to donate millions to ‘fraudulent’ Vatican …

To advoluntas: The action is against the USCB as a body. Should it succeed it is they who will be liable for any damages. But you are right getting any refund from the avaricious antipope francis and his thugs is not going to happen.

A Sister in Liturgical Action

You claim to be a catholic yet call your church "modernist".
St Pius X called modernism the synthesis of all errors.
The catholic church in its nature under current pope benedict xvi is the exact same church it was under Pius xii.
Sadly a thug antipope named francis has wormed his way into it but he will soon be gone.
It is increasingly clear to me now that you are indeed a sedevacantist and …More
You claim to be a catholic yet call your church "modernist".
St Pius X called modernism the synthesis of all errors.
The catholic church in its nature under current pope benedict xvi is the exact same church it was under Pius xii.
Sadly a thug antipope named francis has wormed his way into it but he will soon be gone.
It is increasingly clear to me now that you are indeed a sedevacantist and thus not a roman catholic.
It is no wonder then that you water carry for francis.

New Philadelphia Archbishop Perez Banned Kneeling At Mass in Cleveland

I thought sedevantists like yourself did not recognize any appointments made by the Vat2 church?

Catholic Archbishop Chaput Replaced By Modernist Francis Partisan

Still on with this crypto sedevacantist nonsense I see.
You have failed monumentally to display a single formal doctrinal heresy made by any of these popes whilst in office that you list.
The alleged "pope" Bergoglio on the other hand has made several doctrinal heresies.
This means he can not be a pope even were he validly elected which is extremely doubtful in itself.
WHEN IS THE PENNY GOIN…More
Still on with this crypto sedevacantist nonsense I see.
You have failed monumentally to display a single formal doctrinal heresy made by any of these popes whilst in office that you list.
The alleged "pope" Bergoglio on the other hand has made several doctrinal heresies.
This means he can not be a pope even were he validly elected which is extremely doubtful in itself.
WHEN IS THE PENNY GOING TO DROP.?

Ruini: What John Paul II Would Have Told the Anti-Celibacy Amazon Bishops

Most catholics with a sense of humour would have seen my remark as a normal light hearted question within the context of the topic under discussion.
You need to lighten up a bit.
Crypto Sedevacantism is doing your head in.

Again: Italian Version of Ratzinger/Sarah Book Disproves Gänswein

"which begs the question how Benedict XVI has been happily sending mail and book drafts back and forth to Cardinal Sarah all these months."

House arrest is a light form of imprisonment often accompanied with privilidges etc.

If happily why was it concealed from his gaoler, the thoroughly obnoxious and poisonous Ganswein?.

The mentally unbalanced antipope can not stand the slightest deviation…More
"which begs the question how Benedict XVI has been happily sending mail and book drafts back and forth to Cardinal Sarah all these months."

House arrest is a light form of imprisonment often accompanied with privilidges etc.

If happily why was it concealed from his gaoler, the thoroughly obnoxious and poisonous Ganswein?.

The mentally unbalanced antipope can not stand the slightest deviation from his mad programme of church destruction and must , like a dirty old hog trample underfoot the slightest stirrings..

What Benedict Writes in the Ratzinger/Sarah Book

Pope Benedict xvi continues to fulfill his apostolic duty as supreme pontiff with a masterly essay on the sacraments of marriage and holy orders.
Thank God.

With the Rosary Against the Marx Church

Of course pope Benedict xvi will be judged by Christ.
All of us will.
Non popes like Francis 1st can be judged by anybody including the local bin man.

Father Drexel’s Prophecies: “Do Not Let Yourself Be Discouraged”

The SSPX now fully support the false pontificate of Francis 1st.
I suspect Archbishop Lefebvre is spinning in his grave.

Catholic Archbishop Chaput Replaced By Modernist Francis Partisan

Every act or appoint by antipope Francis is illicit
Perez has no legal ecclesiastical authority.

Archbishop Stands Up For Faith - Polish Bishops Are "Sorry"

The schisms engineered by antipope francis widen and deepen.

Again: Italian Version of Ratzinger/Sarah Book Disproves Gänswein

Poor Pope Benedict xvi is under house arrest and surrounded by scheming liars.
Antipope Francis continues his campaign of destruction and terror.

Francis: King David Was “Handsome” But “Behaved Silly”, “Did Not Pray Every Day”

There is no “pope” francis. Excommunicated formal heretics like him are not members of the Catholic Church.
His claims are devoid of any authority whatsoever.

Ruini: What John Paul II Would Have Told the Anti-Celibacy Amazon Bishops

To Ultraviolet: What’s with the bitter sarcasm?

Cardinal Müller: Francis Engages in "A Vain Effort" When Speaking to Scalfari

Perhaps he does. But is he right in thinking that.?
For any person to think that francis is a pope would mean accepting an individual who openly rejects the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist and many of His core teachings.

Cardinal Müller: Francis Engages in "A Vain Effort" When Speaking to Scalfari

To Dr Bobus. We may on the same page.Thank you.
Benedict still speaks in Peters name.

Ruini: What John Paul II Would Have Told the Anti-Celibacy Amazon Bishops

Has anybody around here ever heard the word dispensation?
Even antipope francis seems on record as favoring priestly celibacy.
What will emerge is a set of new norms on dispensations from celibacy.

"If Celibacy Becomes Optional, It Degenerates into A Lifestyle"

Rothweiler fails utterly to understand that dispensations from the rule of celibacy can and are permitted within the discipline of Roman Catholic holy orders.

Ratzinger/Sarah Book: Francis Was "Really Upset", "Pitched The Fit"

It comes in under the canonical crime of sacrilegious blasphemy.
The penalty is excommunication from the life of the church.
In former times death by burning at the stake .
Rather draconian but it put an end to the spreading of spiritual poison.

Ratzinger/Sarah Book: Francis Was "Really Upset", "Pitched The Fit"

You repeatedly fail to distinguish between material and formal doctrinal heresy.
Bergoglio is the first alleged “pope” in the history of the church to promote formal heresy (Amoris Laetitia).
You can blather all you want about other popes mistakes and material heresies but none of the ever sought to blatantly overturn the commandments of the new and Old Testament

Church Is Two Hundred Years Behind: Behind What?

Martinis deathbed statement about the church being 200 years out of date reveals a very superficial understanding .
It is therefore entirely unsurprising that the utterly superficial antipope francis would both quote and revere that spiritual dilettante.

Francis’ New People in 2020

Little point in continuing this argument where you falsely and wrongly impute doctrinal heresy whilst in office to Pope Benedict and his predecessors since Pius xii.
In addition you falsely impute doctrinal heresy to popes like the Borgia etc.
There has been no doctrinal heresy imparted by any pope ever .
That is until Bergoglio published Amoris Laetitia which is replete with doctrinal errors …More
Little point in continuing this argument where you falsely and wrongly impute doctrinal heresy whilst in office to Pope Benedict and his predecessors since Pius xii.
In addition you falsely impute doctrinal heresy to popes like the Borgia etc.
There has been no doctrinal heresy imparted by any pope ever .
That is until Bergoglio published Amoris Laetitia which is replete with doctrinal errors and heresies concerning the sacrament of marriage.
This another reason Bergoglio can not be a valid pope.
You have failed to address fully or properly any of the multiple arguments I have presented concerning the contemporary catholic Petrine office.
You claim to be a catholic yet think that God permits his divine church to be polluted with false teaching.
That is not and never has been an acceptable catholic position.

A Catastrophic Synodal Path

Hello Michael Matt.
Why, o why ,do you continue to believe against all reason and against all evidence that francis aka jorge bergoglio is some sort of “pope”?
Whether Pope Benedict resigned/ did not resign the papal office is a different issue.
In continuing to recognize francis as a valid pope you effectively hold that Christ permits a visible formal public heretic to rule and lead His Church. …More
Hello Michael Matt.
Why, o why ,do you continue to believe against all reason and against all evidence that francis aka jorge bergoglio is some sort of “pope”?
Whether Pope Benedict resigned/ did not resign the papal office is a different issue.
In continuing to recognize francis as a valid pope you effectively hold that Christ permits a visible formal public heretic to rule and lead His Church.
That is what you are doing.
Please think about it.

Vatican Wanted “Conservative” Bergoglio as Jesuit Commissioner

I would question the veracity of that opening post. Why would bergoglio, himself a dodgy Jesuit, ever be tasked by the Vatican to investigate his own order?
Such a job would normally always go to a non Jesuit priest.
Bertone is a total oddball and his shape throwing about the Fatima Secret was disgusting.
In addition his revolting conduct surrounding the corrupt practices revealed in the massivel…More
I would question the veracity of that opening post. Why would bergoglio, himself a dodgy Jesuit, ever be tasked by the Vatican to investigate his own order?
Such a job would normally always go to a non Jesuit priest.
Bertone is a total oddball and his shape throwing about the Fatima Secret was disgusting.
In addition his revolting conduct surrounding the corrupt practices revealed in the massively expensive renovation of his Rome penthouse was staggering.
Not a man to be trusted with anything.

Cardinal Müller: Francis Fosters “Man-Made One-World-Religion Without Trinity And Incarnation”

He , agreed is not perfect, however from the bunch of apostates that now comprise the now decadent catholic college of cardinals who else is there.
.Burke?
Maybe.
Time will tell.

Francis: King David Was “Handsome” But “Behaved Silly”, “Did Not Pray Every Day”

The unfortunate and now excommunicated bergoglio is immersed in the heresy of immanentism, where objective reasoning and reality is cast aside in favor of subjective religious experience.
St. Pius X warned very directly about this problem not so long ago.

Those polluted with immanentism will concoct all sorts of vain nonsense to justify their flight from reality.
Most perniciously they seek to …More
The unfortunate and now excommunicated bergoglio is immersed in the heresy of immanentism, where objective reasoning and reality is cast aside in favor of subjective religious experience.
St. Pius X warned very directly about this problem not so long ago.

Those polluted with immanentism will concoct all sorts of vain nonsense to justify their flight from reality.
Most perniciously they seek to destroy the transcendent nature of God and always attack those who acknowledge that nature.
This is why bergoglio truly hates , with extreme venom , faithful Catholics who uphold the doctrinal teaching of the Catholic Church.

Ratzinger/Sarah Book: Francis Was "Really Upset", "Pitched The Fit"

It is astounding that Michael Matt continues to accept bergoglio as a valid pope.
The intellectual inconsistency of his position is of course replicated throughout most of the Catholic world which sees no harm in its alleged visible head spitting directly on the face of Christ.

Cardinal Müller: Francis Engages in "A Vain Effort" When Speaking to Scalfari

At least the good cardinal Muller acknowledges and states that Benedict’s conduct in 2013 caused and still causes mental trauma for Catholics.
In addition he asks for theological clarity concerning the relationship between Benedict and his putative successor.
Muller also upholds the teaching concerning no Holy Communion for practising adulterers.
Interesting times ahead.

Cardinal Müller: Francis Engages in "A Vain Effort" When Speaking to Scalfari

TO DR BOBUS WHO DOES NOT WISH TO BE CONTACTED.
Cardinal Muller has the authority of a catholic bishop and a member of the (discredited) college of cardinals.
He can act by bringing to the attention of the faithful that bergoglio aka francis is not a pope anymore having been excommunicated for formal heresy.

Cardinal Müller: Francis Fosters “Man-Made One-World-Religion Without Trinity And Incarnation”

Muller is seeking to preserve his sanity and his position.As a cardinal he is intellectually working out what he genuinely thinks is the situation.
But he refuses to follow through with rigor his acceptance that Benedict’s so called resignation has caused mental trauma in the church .
He calls for a theological explanation of clarity concerning the outcome but it is rather weak.
He is defending “…More
Muller is seeking to preserve his sanity and his position.As a cardinal he is intellectually working out what he genuinely thinks is the situation.
But he refuses to follow through with rigor his acceptance that Benedict’s so called resignation has caused mental trauma in the church .
He calls for a theological explanation of clarity concerning the outcome but it is rather weak.
He is defending “pope” Francis becuase one feels he must do this .
But it lacks conviction.
Muller I think would make a good pope not because of his defects but because of his sincerity.

Cardinal Müller: Francis Fosters “Man-Made One-World-Religion Without Trinity And Incarnation”

I have always liked card.Muller.
But he remains confused about who is the real pope.His essay is remarkable and well worth reading.
His references to Immanentisn correctly summarrise the heresies of Bergoglio.
His call for theological clarity on the Petrine succession will probably go unheeded.
His admission that Benedict’s conduct in 2013 caused a mental trauma though welcome provides no rationa…More
I have always liked card.Muller.
But he remains confused about who is the real pope.His essay is remarkable and well worth reading.
His references to Immanentisn correctly summarrise the heresies of Bergoglio.
His call for theological clarity on the Petrine succession will probably go unheeded.
His admission that Benedict’s conduct in 2013 caused a mental trauma though welcome provides no rational explanation.
fssp.com/immanentism-cat…

Francis’ New People in 2020

To Ultraviolet:You continue to ignore the unique situation that has arisen in the church since 2013 with a superficial acceptance of the utter novelty of a so called “Pope Emeritus “
There can be no such thing as some cardinals have stated.
You also ignore Pope Benedict’s failures to comply with canon law strictures with regard to resignation requirements.

You then seek to argue that because I …More
To Ultraviolet:You continue to ignore the unique situation that has arisen in the church since 2013 with a superficial acceptance of the utter novelty of a so called “Pope Emeritus “
There can be no such thing as some cardinals have stated.
You also ignore Pope Benedict’s failures to comply with canon law strictures with regard to resignation requirements.

You then seek to argue that because I do not excoriate previous popes or Benedict that my condemnation of Bergoglio is somehow hypocritical.
In the light of a unique and unprecedented situation in the Catholic Church I can only and will only concentrate on the problems surrounding the contemporary papacy.

In addition I do not champion Pope Benedict who is the architect of this utterly confusing and damaging situation.

The so called bad popes you mention never altered church doctrinal teaching.

For the first time in church history an alleged pope (Bergoglio )is teaching that it’s ok to commit adultery and then receive Holy Communion without purpose of amendment.

Such teaching is formally heretical

Such teaching directly contravenes the 6th commandment and Christ’s specific words.

And yet you insist that francis is a valid pope?


That is simply not possible.

Whatever the argument about Benedict, a formal heretic like francis can not be an authentic Vicar of Christ.

That is the nub of the argument.

Catholic marriage is indissoluble.
Jorge Bergoglios writings and teaching seek to destroy that charism and promote sacrilegious Holy Communion.

Such teaching as that has no precedent and can only come from a man who is not a member of the Mystical Body of Christ.

No catholic “pope “in history has ever sought to so radically up end and over turn Christ’s very own words on adultery.

I reject your false accusation of hypocrisy.

The real hypocrites are those who follow a pope who panders to the lusts of man by telling them their evil conduct is acceptable to God.

But follow wolf in sheep’s clothing Jorge Bergoglio if that is your choice.

My choice is to reject a false teacher like Bergoglio and look elsewhere.
Benedict is very far from perfect but at least he still lives and is also a Roman Catholic.

Are you a Roman Catholic?
If you are a sincere one then you can not follow Bergoglio as he is most definitely not a catholic .

Any way I appreciate your responses and thank you for taking the time.

Why did Benedict XVI remove his name from Cardinal Sarah's Book? with Bree Dail (Dr Marshall #358)

Why? Because Benedict’s house arrest officer Ganswein told him that unless he did so he (Ganswein) would be replaced and Benedict’s safety would no longer be guaranteed.

French Intellectual Sentenced to 2 Months in Prison For Calling Mass Immigration an “Invasion” – …

This is the established order engineered in part by antipope Francis who wants all restrictions lifted and a free for all for immigration.
His hatred of humanity is especially vitriolic toward Europeans.
(This antipope resides in considerable luxury in the Vatican City state which itself totally prohibits all immigration.)

Oligarch Newspaper Apologises To Westray Hermits

I hope he sues the bastards for millions.

Francis Means to Insult Others, Insults Instead Himself

It is almost certain Francis was never canonically elected pope. But giving him the benefit of the doubt it is now certain he has lost the papacy due to pertinacious manifest and public formal heresy.
He therefore has no authority whatsoever over any catholic
The Catholic Church functions on the basis of spiritual authority and the sole living human source of that authority can only now be , …More
It is almost certain Francis was never canonically elected pope. But giving him the benefit of the doubt it is now certain he has lost the papacy due to pertinacious manifest and public formal heresy.
He therefore has no authority whatsoever over any catholic
The Catholic Church functions on the basis of spiritual authority and the sole living human source of that authority can only now be , problematic as it is, Pope Benedict xvi.

Brazilian Religious Assure Francis of “Unconditional Obedience”, Slam Critics

This poor deceived nun is but one of many thousands of male and female professed catholic religious who follow antipope francis.
They have all blindfolded themselves to the formal heresies of Bergoglio and now prostrate themselves in worship of a dangerous spiritual imposter.

Francis: Church Must Submit To "Our Common Humanity"

This objective stated by the antipope Francis is based on the goals of Freemasonry .
All Catholics are advised to shun the excommunicated Jorge Bergoglio aka francis who still remains a serious threat to their eternal salvation,

Francis’ New People in 2020

If you want to follow what you describe as a godless pope ( bergoglio) that,s your free and reckless .choice.

A godless pope is a contradiction in terms.
Bergoglio is indeed godless and therefore not a pope.
I have never heard historically of a godless pope so refute your assertion in that regard.
I’m not going to argue the apostolic succession as you seem to believe it ended with Pius xii.
I …More
If you want to follow what you describe as a godless pope ( bergoglio) that,s your free and reckless .choice.

A godless pope is a contradiction in terms.
Bergoglio is indeed godless and therefore not a pope.
I have never heard historically of a godless pope so refute your assertion in that regard.
I’m not going to argue the apostolic succession as you seem to believe it ended with Pius xii.
I believe it continues today in Benedict xvi.

Francis’ New People in 2020

These are unprecedented times for every catholic.All that concerns me is the present where you have two men officially wielding the title of “pope” in the Roman Catholic Church
All the other popes you refer to are dead.
Canon law is the sole protection for Catholics in this calamitous situation.
Pope Benedict has not complied fully with it in relation to his resignation.
Antipope Bergoglio daily …More
These are unprecedented times for every catholic.All that concerns me is the present where you have two men officially wielding the title of “pope” in the Roman Catholic Church
All the other popes you refer to are dead.
Canon law is the sole protection for Catholics in this calamitous situation.
Pope Benedict has not complied fully with it in relation to his resignation.
Antipope Bergoglio daily spits on faithful Catholics and openly rejects catholic doctrine.
The safe prudent course all Catholics are obliged to follow is to deem Benedict’s resignation faulty or to view the See of Peter as vacant.
I chose the former.

Vatican Gets Weepy Cardinal: Tagle Breaks Out In Tears Again (Video)

No it does not.
All popes since Pius x11 were valid popes up to and including the current pope Benedict.
All their appointments are both valid and licit.
The appointments mad by any antipope , including bergoglio are probably valid but illicit.
Reminder: PLEASE Pay attention to the following distinctions. Valid/Licit, Formal /Materal.
[Until you grasp these basic concepts you will not advance].

Francis As Head Of The German-Amazonic Church?

Im instructing you concerning the many errors you hold about the Roman Catholic faith.
Chief among these is the view that the liturgy is paramount.
It is not and never has been.

Bishop Raúl Vera Celebrates Homosex Mass

There has been a decline in general ecclesiastical discipline following the 2nd Vat Council.
The liturgy is not the cause of this collapse but where abuses occur , a symptom.
[This focus on liturgy as the primal source of catholicism is erroneous in the extreme.
You seem to be unaware that catholicism is a living religion made of living human beings worshipping the one true God Jesus Christ …More
There has been a decline in general ecclesiastical discipline following the 2nd Vat Council.
The liturgy is not the cause of this collapse but where abuses occur , a symptom.
[This focus on liturgy as the primal source of catholicism is erroneous in the extreme.
You seem to be unaware that catholicism is a living religion made of living human beings worshipping the one true God Jesus Christ who is its Head.
The liturgy exists to serve these catholics not the other way around.]

Francis’ New People in 2020

It would be nice if you studied the distinction between formal and material heresy.
Roncalli and all popes after him were not formal heretics.
Pope Benedict is not a formal heretic.
Antipope Bergoglio definitely is a formal heretic.
The liturgy of the mass is largely a man made affair.
It can and has been changed over the centuries and to assert that it is set in stone by PiusV is absurd and …More
It would be nice if you studied the distinction between formal and material heresy.
Roncalli and all popes after him were not formal heretics.
Pope Benedict is not a formal heretic.
Antipope Bergoglio definitely is a formal heretic.
The liturgy of the mass is largely a man made affair.
It can and has been changed over the centuries and to assert that it is set in stone by PiusV is absurd and factually incorrect.

Heroic Cardinal Sarah Met Benedict - Lying Gänswein Rebutted

The basic issue is papal authority. Any pope has full authority over all liturgical rites.
If he wants to change them he can. Popes prior to Pius x11 did so.
To claim that a pope could bind every future pope for all time on the liturgy of the Holy Mass is absurd and irrational.
The mass itself developed organically since the Last Supper and to claim that Pius V could freeze the mass forever in …More
The basic issue is papal authority. Any pope has full authority over all liturgical rites.
If he wants to change them he can. Popes prior to Pius x11 did so.
To claim that a pope could bind every future pope for all time on the liturgy of the Holy Mass is absurd and irrational.
The mass itself developed organically since the Last Supper and to claim that Pius V could freeze the mass forever in its then form in the 16th century is deeply irrational.
F rancis is not a pope since the Chair of St Peter remains occupied by Pope Benedict.
If I am wrong on that then F rancis is not a pope because he is a public formal heretic and such can not be a pope.

There Is Already A Schism: Two Religions In One Church

Er no. Paul V I was a valid pope who changed liturgical rites.
As supreme pontiff he had that authority an d was not bound in liturgical matters by any of his predecessors.
The core doctrines of the catholic church have remained the same before and since Paul V I .
[The current catholic church is experiencing a papal crisis with two popes a false one [bergoglio] who publishes false doctrine and …More
Er no. Paul V I was a valid pope who changed liturgical rites.
As supreme pontiff he had that authority an d was not bound in liturgical matters by any of his predecessors.
The core doctrines of the catholic church have remained the same before and since Paul V I .
[The current catholic church is experiencing a papal crisis with two popes a false one [bergoglio] who publishes false doctrine and a real one [ the elderly and frail Benedict xvi ] who is under house arrest by bergoglio sedated and under control of his guard Ganswein.

Heroic Cardinal Sarah Met Benedict - Lying Gänswein Rebutted

To Mattsixteen You said "Suspending the Latin Rite Mass is not a "mere liturgical matter".
But the mass is entirely a liturgical matter and the rites of mass are decided upon by the pope and the bishops. A pope can not bind every future pope on a matter of liturgy and those who claim that Pius V could so do are incorrect.
In addition the Latin Mass was never abrogated according to current Pope …More
To Mattsixteen You said "Suspending the Latin Rite Mass is not a "mere liturgical matter".
But the mass is entirely a liturgical matter and the rites of mass are decided upon by the pope and the bishops. A pope can not bind every future pope on a matter of liturgy and those who claim that Pius V could so do are incorrect.
In addition the Latin Mass was never abrogated according to current Pope Benedict xvi.

Amazon Priesthood “Denies Sacramental Character of Catholic Priesthood”

Celibacy is neither a church doctrinal or gospel matter.
It is basically a matter of church discipline.
St.Peter was a married man.

Any change therefore in the requirement of mandatory celibacy would have nothing to do with church doctrine.

There Is Already A Schism: Two Religions In One Church

The Novus Ordo mass is valid. It may not be licit but transubstantiation occurs.
The priests who officiate at Novus Ordo masses are as a rule also validly ordained.
There is no FALSE CHURCH within catholocism merely false doctrines held by catholics..
But what does exist is a frightening and false pope called francis [real name jorge bergoglio] and a real pope called Benedict xvi.

With the Rosary Against the Marx Church

Francis aka Jorge Bergoglio sj is currently a public formal pertinacious heretic.
It is contrary to all Catholic Church teaching that such an individual could remain a pope even if , which is doubtful, validly elected.