en.news
203.1K

Benedict Contradicts Himself: "The Reigning Pope Has Possiblitiy To Forbid Roman Mass"

Highlights from Archbishop Gänswein’s 330-page book Nothing But The Truth - My Life Beside Benedict XVI.

• As John Paul II lay dying, Cardinal Ratzinger watched the Curia prelates fight among themselves for power, and Benedict later resigned partly because he did not want to "end up like him."

• Cardinal Sodano disagreed with Benedict's choice of Tarcisio Bertone as his successor as Secretary of State for lacking diplomatic experience. Gänswein calls Cardinal Bertone an inefficient and absent Secretary of State who mishandled the problems of the Vatican's bank.

• When Benedict told Gänswein in September 2012 that he will resign, Gänswein tried to convince him to slow down rather then step down. Benedict refused and began thinking of the best timing for such a step which turned out to be the worst.

• Gänswein repeatedly stresses that Benedict resigned of his own free will and in full awareness.

• Benedict had the "naïve" hope that Gänswein would be the link between him and his successor, but already after a few months, "I had the impression that between me and the new pope a climate of trust had not been created.”

• After Francis called Benedict a "wise grandfather," Benedict retorted, "I'm only 9 years older than him."

• After giving a long interview to a Jesuit magazine in 2013, Francis asked Benedict for his comments, who in an annotated response criticised how Francis had spoken about abortion and homosexuality.

• Benedict was “surprised” that Francis ignored the 2016 Dubia of the four Cardinals on Amoris Laetitia.

• Gänswein calls Cardinal Sarah's 2020 Twitter.com statements that Benedict XVI was the co-author of his book on celibacy “inopportune.” Sarah wanted Benedict XVI to sign a January 2020 press statement on the book-saga but he refused.

• Gänswein asked Benedict in 2021 what he thought about Francis’ decision to “forbid” the Roman Rite, and he replied that “the reigning pope has the responsibility to make decisions like this and must act according to what he believes is the good of the Church, but on a personal level, he saw it as a definite change of course and believed it was a mistake.”

• Benedict always was saddened by attempts to portray him and Francis as opponents, “especially when the observation came from within the Vatican.”

• Benedict gave Gänswein written instruction to destroy all private notices after death, like John Paul II whose wish was disregarded by his secretary.

Picture: © Mazur/cbcew.org.uk, CC BY-NC-ND, #newsSfpeuxlvry


Wilma Lopez
About Benedict's silence about AL: "However, as with many other aspects of Francis’s papacy noted in the book, Benedict refused to weigh in publicly, nor did he “respond to the questions that had come to him, since that would have been an illicit intrusion,” wrote Gänswein."
la verdad prevalece
The book written by the modernist apostate George Gänswein on Pope Benedict XVI contradicts the teachings of Pope Benedict XVI: Pope Benedict: Popes Can’t Scrap Liturgy (churchmilitant.com)
"Even the supreme authority in the Church may not change the liturgy arbitrarily"
In his book review, Cdl. Ratzinger, then prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, explained how the pope is …More
The book written by the modernist apostate George Gänswein on Pope Benedict XVI contradicts the teachings of Pope Benedict XVI: Pope Benedict: Popes Can’t Scrap Liturgy (churchmilitant.com)

"Even the supreme authority in the Church may not change the liturgy arbitrarily"

In his book review, Cdl. Ratzinger, then prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, explained how the pope is bound by the organic truth of the liturgy and must use his authority to protect that truth:

[T]he catechism, in mentioning the limitation of the powers of the supreme authority in the Church with regard to reform, recalls to mind what is the essence of the primacy as outlined by the First and Second Vatican Councils: The pope is not an absolute monarch whose will is law but is the guardian of the authentic Tradition and thereby the premier guarantor of obedience. He cannot do as he likes and is thereby able to oppose those people who for their part want to do what has come into their head. His rule is not that of arbitrary power but that of obedience in faith. That is why, with respect to the liturgy, he has the task of a gardener, not that of a technician who builds new machines and throws the old ones on the junk-pile.
Werte
Benedict XVI only found out about «Traditionis custodes» when he read «L'Osservatore Romano»... 🙁
DrMaria
Believe the words actually given to us by Pope Benedict XVI, in print, regarding the TLM, when he issued Summorum Pontificum : “What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us too, and it cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful.” Anything else is mere hearsay and without any basis in fact~~~.
yuca2111
This is good, it doesn't look that way right now, but, it will be seen in the future as evidence, a part of history about the time when a false prophet and a true prophet lives. This is, as cardenal Burke once said about this time in history, it would be seen as a black mark in the history of the Church. It is IMPORTANT the facts archbishop Ganswein is making on how sad he was on how the Vatican …More
This is good, it doesn't look that way right now, but, it will be seen in the future as evidence, a part of history about the time when a false prophet and a true prophet lives. This is, as cardenal Burke once said about this time in history, it would be seen as a black mark in the history of the Church. It is IMPORTANT the facts archbishop Ganswein is making on how sad he was on how the Vatican was piting Benedict vs Francis. In the end, we could see the results for ourselves, Francis throughout his reign time and time again eclipsed, or destroyed everything Benedict did. Falseness is the currency about this false prophet.
Hound of Heaven
It seems to me that someone had an awful lot of time on his hands to write a memoir when the Lord's teachings are being challenged on a daily basis. Our Lord asked for more workers for His vineyard, not memoirs on how the bitter grapes are growing. Our Lord is already 'nothing but The Truth'. Work on spreading the Gospel rather than this codswallop.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
If that's Ganswein, he has the face of a serpent.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
" After Francis called Benedict a "wise grandfather," Benedict retorted, "I'm only 9 years older than him."" Benedict XVI was no fool. He knew Francis was decieving himself. Francis is supposedly sicker now, at 86, than Benedict XVI was at 95. Francis has serious problems which are never mentioned. I would not be surprised if Francis survives Benedict by only 5-6 months....missing out on creating …More
" After Francis called Benedict a "wise grandfather," Benedict retorted, "I'm only 9 years older than him."" Benedict XVI was no fool. He knew Francis was decieving himself. Francis is supposedly sicker now, at 86, than Benedict XVI was at 95. Francis has serious problems which are never mentioned. I would not be surprised if Francis survives Benedict by only 5-6 months....missing out on creating the "Synoda; Church" he is in love with so much. And when he does go, 1/4 of the amount of people who came to visit Benedict will pass thru to visit Francis body in St.Peters.
sarto2010
Francis is a fat, useless waster.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
Yes, and now he's trying to implement his "Synodal Church" in Rome with new directives. He can shove his "Synodal Church" model up his a--.
DrMaria
serpens
Werte
Archbishop Gänswein claims that the Dictator Pope humiliated him in public numerous times and that no money is being saved by Francis not living in the Apostolic Palace since the place has to be maintained.
la verdad prevalece
Gänswein has betrayed the faith, he has apostatized, he is a modernist heretic accomplice of Bergoglio, he is a traitor who is at the service of the anti-church. No one can serve two masters at the same time. He is not a true servant of Christ, therefore he serves the antichrist.
DrMaria
Thank you, Lord, for Bishop Athanasius Schneider!!
Ivan Tomas
Nobody should have the slightest trust in Gänswein or in the entire Opus Dei society.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
Poor Benedict XVI trusted Ganswein. Benedict XVI was a wonderful man and Pope. Ganswein is probably just another homosexual, now looking for favor with Francis. Waste of his time though, 'cause Francis will be dead within months, and his "Synodal Church" dead too. So they'll be no place for "gorgeous Georg" as he was labeled when Benedict was first Elected.
Sandy Barrett
“Dear friends, may no adversity paralyze you. Be afraid neither of the world, nor of the future, nor of your weakness. The Lord has allowed you to live in this moment of history so that, by your faith, his name will continue to resound throughout the world.” - Pope Benedict XVI
pauljamesdwyer
His chance to even the score, all BS!
Orthocat
Gosh, all these bombshell tell-all books: 1st Prince Harry, now Gänswein. Why do I think "traitors"? 🤔