"The criterion of truth is not that of journalism,..."...and today we discover
Frà Alexis Bugnolo doesn't understand the difference between journalistic standards and
legal ones.
The latter are vitally important if we, as Catholics, seek to emulate Christ's focus on the truth -as opposed to breathlessly repeating sensationalistic gossip
Further, I didn't make any implication about Fr. Hesse's honesty. I'll gladly give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he's a truthful man who believed everything he said.
He might also believe his relative was truthful as well. For that matter, his relative might even genuinely believe everything
they said. However, that does not prove
anything the relative said was, in fact,
true.
His relative might be rational yet factually incorrect. His relative might be neurotic and prone to delusions. We live in a world filled with thousands of people who genuinely believe they were abducted by extraterrestrials. There are thousands of others who genuinely believe they
are extraterrestrials.
Father Hesse wasn't a first-hand witness to the information he's relating. It's second-hand at best. His own personal honesty is no guarantee for his relative's honesty, rationality or accuracy.