"It is a fatal error to hold that a heretic is a valid pope and that those who separate from a heretic leave the Church and are schismatics."
Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò has the right to express a personal judgement, which is his right to conscience.
Although A TRUE POPE CANNOT fall under the jurisdiction of the Church (or even a future or past pope - as an equal cannot judge an equal), A DUBIOUS POPE CAN fall under its jurisdiction. According to the Church's teaching and canonical tradition, AN HERETICAL OCCUPANT OF THE PAPAL THRONE CAN BE JUDGED by the Church. A heretic is an incapable subject of the papacy, for which reasons the canonical tradition of the Church rules that A HERETIC IS NOT A VALID POPE.
A heretic can't be a true pope. IT IS A FATAL ERROR TO SAY THAT A HERETIC IS A VALID POPE AND THAT THOSE WHO SEPARATE FROM A HERETIC LEAVE THE CHURCH AND ARE SCHISMATICS. But the heretic is an anti-pope who defects from the Church. Those who separate from him remain in the Church. But those who remain under the heretic follow him out of the Church into schism.
It is not Vigano's private opinion but is an evident and undeniable fact that the Bergoglian magisterium officially teaches heresy against the Catholic faith...
See: IS IT ONLY MY OPINION, OR IS BERGOGLIO THE HEAD OF A FALSE CHURCH? – Ecclesia Militans and It Is Jorge Bergoglio Who Must Be Removed by the Church – Ecclesia Militans and It Is a Fatal Error to Say that the Heretic Is a Valid Pope – Ecclesia Militans and The Counterfeit Church – Ecclesia Militans and Rewind – What Is the Difference between the Conciliar Popes and Jorge Bergoglio? – Fr. Paul Kramer Answers – Ecclesia Militans and WHY DOES DR. MAZZA REFUSE TO DEBATE JOHN SALZA? HE DOES SO FOR GOOD REASON. – Ecclesia Militans and The Synodal Church Is a False and Schismatic Church – Ecclesia Militans and Rewind – The Conciliar Church Is a Transitional Church – Ecclesia Militans and The Eternal Hell Is a Dogma of Faith – Ecclesia Militans and Archbishop Vigano Declares That Francis Has Betrayed The Papacy and It Is Jorge Bergoglio Who Must Be Removed by the Church – Ecclesia Militans
Although A TRUE POPE CANNOT fall under the jurisdiction of the Church (or even a future or past pope - as an equal cannot judge an equal), A DUBIOUS POPE CAN fall under its jurisdiction. According to the Church's teaching and canonical tradition, AN HERETICAL OCCUPANT OF THE PAPAL THRONE CAN BE JUDGED by the Church. A heretic is an incapable subject of the papacy, for which reasons the canonical tradition of the Church rules that A HERETIC IS NOT A VALID POPE.
A heretic can't be a true pope. IT IS A FATAL ERROR TO SAY THAT A HERETIC IS A VALID POPE AND THAT THOSE WHO SEPARATE FROM A HERETIC LEAVE THE CHURCH AND ARE SCHISMATICS. But the heretic is an anti-pope who defects from the Church. Those who separate from him remain in the Church. But those who remain under the heretic follow him out of the Church into schism.
It is not Vigano's private opinion but is an evident and undeniable fact that the Bergoglian magisterium officially teaches heresy against the Catholic faith...
See: IS IT ONLY MY OPINION, OR IS BERGOGLIO THE HEAD OF A FALSE CHURCH? – Ecclesia Militans and It Is Jorge Bergoglio Who Must Be Removed by the Church – Ecclesia Militans and It Is a Fatal Error to Say that the Heretic Is a Valid Pope – Ecclesia Militans and The Counterfeit Church – Ecclesia Militans and Rewind – What Is the Difference between the Conciliar Popes and Jorge Bergoglio? – Fr. Paul Kramer Answers – Ecclesia Militans and WHY DOES DR. MAZZA REFUSE TO DEBATE JOHN SALZA? HE DOES SO FOR GOOD REASON. – Ecclesia Militans and The Synodal Church Is a False and Schismatic Church – Ecclesia Militans and Rewind – The Conciliar Church Is a Transitional Church – Ecclesia Militans and The Eternal Hell Is a Dogma of Faith – Ecclesia Militans and Archbishop Vigano Declares That Francis Has Betrayed The Papacy and It Is Jorge Bergoglio Who Must Be Removed by the Church – Ecclesia Militans